New MP3 Player

My old Creative Zen Micro is dying slowly (the headphone jack will only produce sound when I hold the headphone just so) and I'm considering a new player. I'm trying to decide between the following:

( Click on the cut to see the toys! )

I'd really love the advice of my flist. Any recommendations, tips, warnings, or general wisdom?

In other news: Lazy Sundays are ever so much nicer with _usakeh_ present.